Tracking the most important health care lawsuits in U.S. courts today
February 11, 2026 | AbbVie challenges selection of Botox for the third cycle of Medicare drug price negotiation
This important alert links to ”How the Litigation Tracker Works
-
Search for a lawsuit or issue More than 350 cases over 17 issues
-
Explore related documentation Extensive library of key filing documents
-
Learn the current status of the case Realtime case updates
-
Read our analysis Read our take on the most pressing cases
Issues We’re Tracking
- 340B Program 20 cases
- Affordable Care Act 69 cases 6 Topics
- Anticompetitive Practices 23 cases 1 Topics
- Artificial Intelligence 3 cases
- Consumer Protections 17 cases 1 Topics
- Cost Containment 13 cases
- Equity 49 cases 1 Topics
- ERISA 16 cases
- Federal Health Funding 42 cases 4 Topics
- Medicare Advantage 23 cases
- Medicare Drug Price Negotiation 22 cases
- No Surprises Act 40 cases 4 Topics
- Prescription Drug Affordability 21 cases 5 Topics
- Reproductive Health 46 cases 5 Topics
- Site-Neutral Payments 9 cases
- Transparency 6 cases

Our Team
We’re the experts on health care litigation. We’re here to make the process of navigating and understanding health care litigation easy.

Katie Keith
Director of the Center for Health Policy and the Law at the O’Neill Institute

Andrew J. Twinamatsiko
Director of the Center for Health Policy and the Law at the O’Neill Institute
Latest Updates
1:25-cv-10346
Association of American Universities et al. v. Department of Health and Human Services et al.
- Filed:
- February 10, 2025
- Status
-
Decision issued
Appeal Filed
- Court
- Massachusetts
- Goal
- Block enforcement of an agency action +1 additional goal(s)
6:25-cv-01748
State of Washington et al. v. Department of Health and Human Services et al.
- Filed:
- September 26, 2025
- Status
- Appeal Filed
- Court
- Oregon
- Goal
- Block enforcement of an agency action +2 additional goal(s)
- Status
-
Briefing is ongoing
Motion for Preliminary Injunction Granted in Part
- Court
- Illinois Northern
- Goal
- Block enforcement of an agency action +2 additional goal(s)
1:25-cv-05571
Cement and Concrete Workers DC Benefit Fund v. The New York and Presbyterian Hospital
- Filed:
- October 3, 2025
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- New York Eastern
- Goal
- Award damages +5 additional goal(s)
- Status
-
Briefing is ongoing
Motion to Dismiss Granted in Part
- Court
- New York Southern
- Goal
- Block unlawful practices +6 additional goal(s)
2:25-cv-07187
UnitedHealthcare of Pennsylvania, Inc. v. NorthStar Anesthesia of Pennsylvania, LLC
- Filed:
- December 19, 2025
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- Pennsylvania Eastern
- Goal
- Award damages +2 additional goal(s)
1:26-cv-00022
State of New York et al. v. Department of Health and Human Services et al.
- Filed:
- January 13, 2026
- Status
- Case Stayed
- Court
- Rhode Island
- Goal
- Block enforcement of an agency action +2 additional goal(s)
1:23-cv-05221
United Healthcare Services, Inc. v. Hospital Physician Services Southeast, P.C. et al.
- Filed:
- November 13, 2023
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- Georgia Northern
- Goal
- Declaration that ERISA and the Supremacy Clause preempt defendants’ non-contractual state-law claims
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- Florida Middle
- Goal
- Award damages +4 additional goal(s)
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- Oregon
- Goal
- Block enforcement of an agency action +2 additional goal(s)
4:23-cv-04398
Electrical Medical Trust et al. v. U.S. Anesthesia Partners, Inc. et al.
- Filed:
- November 20, 2023
- Status
- Briefing is ongoing
- Court
- Texas Southern
- Goal
- Award damages +3 additional goal(s)
- Status
- Case Dismissed
- Court
- New York Southern
- Goal
- Block defendant action +1 additional goal(s)
Key Dates
Defendant’s Notice Due
Plaintiffs’ Response to Motions to Dismiss Due
Hearing on Motion to Reassign Case
Hearing on Motion to Dismiss
Plaintiffs’ Response to Cross Motion for Summary Judgment Due
Plaintiffs’ Response to Motion for Summary Judgment Due
Plaintiffs’ Reply Brief Due
Oral Argument
Joint Proposed Protective Order Due
Proposed Intervenors’ Response to Order to Show Cause Due
Defendants’ Opening Brief Due
Defendant’s Brief Due
Defendants’ Response to Intervenor’s Complaint Due
Replies to Dispositive Motions Due
Amended Complaint Due
Motions to Amend the Pleadings or for Joinder of Additional Parties Due
Plaintiff’s Expert Disclosure Due
Defendants’ Reply Brief Due
Defendants’ Deadline for Production of Documents
Defendants’ Response Brief Due
Plaintiffs’ Response to Motion to Dismiss Due
Defendants’ Reply Brief Due
Defendants’ Reply Brief Re: Motion to Dismiss Due
Defendants’ Third Brief Due
Defendants’ Opening Brief Due
Joint Status Report Due
Hearing on Motion to Compel
Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Due
Defendants’ Answer Due
Joint Status Report Due
Scheduling Conference
Status Conference
Joint Status Report Due
Amended Pleadings Due
Defendant’s Brief Due
Response to Motion for Summary Judgment Due
Discovery Deadline
Defendants’ Opening Brief Due
Defendants’ Opening Brief Due
Petition for Approval of Settlement Due
Deadline for Plaintiff to Join Additional Parties
Plaintiff’s Brief Due
Oral Argument
Status Conference
Case Management Conference
Joint Status Update Due
Response Due
Plaintiffs’ Response Brief Due
Joint Status Report Due
In the News
• Health Affairs
Challenges To Anti-Competitive Hospital Contracting Practices: The New York And Presbyterian Hospital
• O’Neill Institute
Recent Developments in Orange Book Litigation: How Patent Disputes Shape Prescription Drug Affordability
• Health Affairs
District Court: Restrictions On Mifepristone Illegal But Will Remain In Effect Pending FDA Reconsideration
• O’Neill Institute