- Docket No.
- 23-40605
- Appellate Court
- Fifth Circuit
Goal
- Declaration that agency action is unlawful
Issues
Case History
Litigation Content
Why this Matters
The plaintiffs argue that regulations outlining the methodology used to calculate the No Surprises Act’s qualifying payment amount (the basis for determining individual cost sharing for items and services covered by the balance-billing protections) are invalid under the Administrative Procedure Act. The design of the qualifying payment amount is critical to the No Surprises Act’s mission to promote lower health care premiums and costs, both for consumers directly for out-of-network services as well as through the arbitration process. The plaintiffs appeal, and defendants cross-appeal a partially denied cross-motion for summary judgment.
Potential Impact
Setting aside the methodology to calculate the qualifying payment amount for health care services in virtually all settings could expose patients to higher cost sharing and make the arbitration process more likely to raise health care costs and premiums.
News And Analysis (1)
44 Major Filings
- AMICUS BRIEF [TEXAS ET AL.] (Sep 16, 2025)
- ORDER (Sep 16, 2025)
- OPPOSED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMICUS BRIEF (Sep 9, 2025)
- DEFENDANTS' REPLY BRIEF (Sep 2, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [PHYSICIANS ADVOCACY INSTITUTE ET AL.] (Aug 28, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICAN SOCIETY OF ANESTHESIOLOGISTS ET AL.] (Aug 28, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION] (Aug 28, 2025)
- PLAINTIFF LIFENET ET AL.’S RESPONSE BRIEF (Aug 18, 2025)
- PLAINTIFF TEXAS MEDICAL ASSOCIATION ET AL.'S RESPONSE BRIEF (Aug 18, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD ASSOCIATION] (Jul 29, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [LEUKEMIA & LYMPHOMA SOCIETY ET AL.] (Jul 29, 2025)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICA'S HEALTH INSURANCE PLANS] (Jul 28, 2025)
- ADDENDUM TO DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE BRIEF (Jul 21, 2025)
- DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE BRIEF (Jul 21, 2025)
- SCHEDULING ORDER (Jul 11, 2025)
- SCHEDULING ORDER (Jul 10, 2025)
- SCHEDULING ORDER (Jun 16, 2025)
- UNOPPOSED SCHEDULING MOTION (Jun 13, 2025)
- ORDER (May 30, 2025)
- DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR REHEARING (Jan 17, 2025)
- ORDER (Dec 17, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' PETITION FOR REHEARING (Dec 16, 2024)
- JUDGMENT (Oct 30, 2024)
- OPINION (Oct 30, 2024)
- DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Aug 8, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Aug 6, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (Jul 9, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jul 8, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jul 8, 2024)
- DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jul 3, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' REPLY BRIEF (Jun 3, 2024)
- DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE BRIEF (May 13, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT PRACTICE MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION] (Mar 20, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [PHYSICIANS ADVOCACY INSTITUTE ET AL.] (Mar 20, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICAN SOCIETY OF ANESTHESIOLOGISTS ET AL.] (Mar 20, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION] (Mar 20, 2024)
- PLAINTIFF LIFENET ET AL.'S RESPONSE BRIEF (Mar 13, 2024)
- PLAINTIFF TEXAS MEDICAL ASSOCIATION ET AL.'S RESPONSE BRIEF (Mar 13, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [LEUKEMIA & LYMPHOMA SOCIETY ET AL.] (Jan 19, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD ASSOCIATION] (Jan 19, 2024)
- AMICUS BRIEF [AMERICA'S HEALTH INSURANCE PLANS] (Jan 19, 2024)
- DEFENDANTS' OPENING BRIEF (Jan 12, 2024)
- PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL (Oct 31, 2023)
- DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF APPEAL (Oct 20, 2023)