- Docket No.
- 23-10326
- Appellate Court
- Fifth Circuit
Goal
- Eliminate guaranteed access to preventive services with no cost-sharing
- Exempt the plaintiffs from the requirement
- Invalidate the provision
Issues
Case History
Litigation Content
Why this Matters:
The plaintiffs argue that the Affordable Care Act’s preventive services requirement is unconstitutional because it violates the Appointments Clause and the nondelegation doctrine. The preventive services requirement is a popular provision of the law that has been in effect since 2010 and extends coverage of evidence-based preventive services (such as cancer screening, tobacco cessation, contraception, and immunizations), without cost-sharing, to more than 150 million people each year. That guaranteed benefit could go away if the courts agree with the plaintiffs.
Potential Impact:
Striking down the requirement for insurers and employers to cover preventive services without cost-sharing would jeopardize access to needed services for consumers.
News And Analysis (4)
59 Major Filings
- ORDER (Jan 14, 2025)
- ORDER (Jan 14, 2025)
- NOTICE (Nov 1, 2024)
- NOTICE (Sep 20, 2024)
- JUDGMENT (Aug 13, 2024)
- OPINION (Jun 21, 2024)
- RESPONSE BY APPELLANTS (Jun 18, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jun 17, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jun 15, 2024)
- Reply to Response to Notice of Supplemental Authority (Mar 26, 2024)
- RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (Mar 21, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (Mar 14, 2024)
- REPLY BRIEF OF CROSS-APPELLANTS (Nov 3, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF NWLC (Oct 6, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF APHA et al. (Oct 6, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AMA et al. (Oct 6, 2023)
- Defendants' RESPONSE AND REPLY BRIEF (Sep 29, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF BUCKEYE INSTITUTE (Aug 14, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF STATE OF TEXAS (Aug 14, 2023)
- BRIEF of Braidwood Management et al. (Aug 7, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AMA et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AIDS Healthcare Foundation (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Gilead Sciences (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF SEIU (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Susan G. Komen (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF NHeLP et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AHA et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Public Health Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Bipartisan Economic Scholars (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AARP (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Illinois et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Lung Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF US of Care et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF BCBSA (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF HIV Medicine Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Cancer Society et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF HIV and Hepatitis Policy Institute et al. (Jun 23, 2023)
- OPENING BRIEF for Federal Defendants (Jun 20, 2023)
- BRIEFING SCHEDULE Letter (Jun 13, 2023)
- ORDER (Jun 13, 2023)
- JOINT STIPULATION (Jun 12, 2023)
- JOINT REPORT on Possible Agreement (Jun 9, 2023)
- ORDER (Jun 7, 2023)
- RESPONSE to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Memorandum (May 31, 2023)
- Supplemental Memorandum (May 26, 2023)
- MOTION for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum (May 25, 2023)
- UNOPPOSED MOTION to Establish Briefing Schedule (May 19, 2023)
- ORDER (May 15, 2023)
- REPLY in Support of Motion for Partial Stay (May 12, 2023)
- RESPONSE to Motion for Partial Stay (May 4, 2023)
- Consent MOTION to file Amicus Brief_AHA et al. (May 4, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_SEIU (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Medical Association et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Public Health Association et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF_American Cancer Society et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Lung Association et al. (Apr 27, 2023)
- MOTION for a Partial Stay of Final Judgment Pending Appeal (Apr 27, 2023)
- NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL (Apr 7, 2023)
- NOTICE OF APPEAL (Apr 3, 2023)