- Docket No.
- 23-10326
- Appellate Court
- Fifth Circuit
Goal
- Eliminate guaranteed access to preventive services with no cost-sharing
- Exempt the plaintiffs from the requirement
- Invalidate the provision
Issues
Case History
Litigation Content
Why this Matters:
The plaintiffs argue that the Affordable Care Act’s preventive services requirement is unconstitutional because it violates the Appointments Clause, the nondelegation doctrine, and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The preventive services requirement is a popular provision of the law that has been in effect since 2010 and extends coverage of evidence-based preventive services (such as cancer screening, tobacco cessation, contraception, and immunizations), without cost-sharing, to more than 150 million people each year. That guaranteed benefit could go away if the courts agree with the plaintiffs.
Potential Impact:
Striking down the requirement for insurers and employers to cover preventive services without cost-sharing would jeopardize access to needed services for consumers.
News And Analysis (4)
55 Major Filings
- JUDGMENT (Aug 13, 2024)
- OPINION (Jun 21, 2024)
- RESPONSE BY APPELLANTS (Jun 18, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jun 17, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (Jun 15, 2024)
- Reply to Response to Notice of Supplemental Authority (Mar 26, 2024)
- RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (Mar 21, 2024)
- NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY (Mar 14, 2024)
- REPLY BRIEF OF CROSS-APPELLANTS (Nov 3, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF NWLC (Oct 6, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF APHA et al. (Oct 6, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AMA et al. (Oct 6, 2023)
- Defendants' RESPONSE AND REPLY BRIEF (Sep 29, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF BUCKEYE INSTITUTE (Aug 14, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF STATE OF TEXAS (Aug 14, 2023)
- BRIEF of Braidwood Management et al. (Aug 7, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AMA et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AIDS Healthcare Foundation (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Gilead Sciences (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF SEIU (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Susan G. Komen (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF NHeLP et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AHA et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Public Health Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Bipartisan Economic Scholars (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF AARP (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF Illinois et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Lung Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF US of Care et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF BCBSA (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF HIV Medicine Association et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF American Cancer Society et al. (Jun 27, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF HIV and Hepatitis Policy Institute et al. (Jun 23, 2023)
- OPENING BRIEF for Federal Defendants (Jun 20, 2023)
- BRIEFING SCHEDULE Letter (Jun 13, 2023)
- ORDER (Jun 13, 2023)
- JOINT STIPULATION (Jun 12, 2023)
- JOINT REPORT on Possible Agreement (Jun 9, 2023)
- ORDER (Jun 7, 2023)
- RESPONSE to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Memorandum (May 31, 2023)
- Supplemental Memorandum (May 26, 2023)
- MOTION for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum (May 25, 2023)
- UNOPPOSED MOTION to Establish Briefing Schedule (May 19, 2023)
- ORDER (May 15, 2023)
- REPLY in Support of Motion for Partial Stay (May 12, 2023)
- RESPONSE to Motion for Partial Stay (May 4, 2023)
- Consent MOTION to file Amicus Brief_AHA et al. (May 4, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_SEIU (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Medical Association et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Public Health Association et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- AMICUS BRIEF_American Cancer Society et al. (Apr 28, 2023)
- Unopposed MOTION to File AMICUS BRIEF_American Lung Association et al. (Apr 27, 2023)
- MOTION for a Partial Stay of Final Judgment Pending Appeal (Apr 27, 2023)
- NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL (Apr 7, 2023)
- NOTICE OF APPEAL (Apr 3, 2023)